On October 1, Year 1, Sterling Corp. purchased 500 shares of Dalton Inc.'s common stock at fair value. This acquisition represents a 30% ownership interest in Dalton, granting Sterling significant influence, and Sterling did not elect the fair value option. The cost per share on October 1, Year 1, was $120.
Dalton's operational data for Year 1 and Year 2 is as follows:
• Year 1 net loss (incurred at a constant monthly rate over 12 months): $24,000
• Year 2 net income: $35,000
• December 31, Year 2 dividend declared and paid: $2.50 per share
Under the equity method, what should be the balance in Sterling's investment account as of December 31, Year 2?
❓ WHY OPTIONS ARE CORRECT/INCORRECT:
✅ Option 2 (Correct): $67,050 is the correct ending investment balance under the equity method. Since Sterling owns a 30% interest and has significant influence, it must use the equity method (ASC 323). The initial cost of the investment is 500 shares * $120 = $60,000. Under the equity method, the investor records its proportionate share of the investee’s earnings or losses from the date of acquisition. For Year 1, Dalton reported a $24,000 net loss over 12 months ($2,000 per month). Because Sterling acquired the stock on October 1, it only owns the shares for 3 months of Year 1. Sterling's share of the Year 1 loss is $24,000 * 3/12 * 30% = $1,800, which reduces the investment account. In Year 2, Sterling records its share of Dalton's net income: $35,000 * 30% = $10,500, which increases the investment account. Finally, dividends received under the equity method reduce the investment balance as a return of capital: 500 shares * $2.50 = $1,250. This yields an ending balance of $60,000 - $1,800 + $10,500 - $1,250 = $67,050. Changes in stock market fair value are completely ignored because the fair value option was not elected.
❌ Option 1 (Incorrect): $57,250 is derived by incorrectly subtracting the full 12 months of Dalton's Year 1 net loss ($24,000 * 30% = $7,200) instead of pro-rating it for the 3 months of actual ownership ($60,000 - $7,200 + $10,500 - $1,250).
❌ Option 3 (Incorrect): $68,300 is derived by failing to subtract the Year 2 cash dividends received from the investment asset balance ($60,000 - $1,800 + $10,500).
❌ Option 4 (Incorrect): $85,000 is a distractor value that represents a completely incorrect application of fair value changes or failing to account for the losses and dividends under equity tracking rules.
📊 SUMMARY CALCULATIONS:
- Initial Investment Cost = 500 shares * $120 = $60,000
- Year 1 Pro-rated Investee Loss Share = $24,000 * (3 / 12 months) * 30% = -$1,800
- Year 2 Investee Income Share = $35,000 * 30% = +$10,500
- Year 2 Dividends Received = 500 shares * $2.50 = -$1,250
- Ending Investment Balance = $60,000 - $1,800 + $10,500 - $1,250 = $67,050
❓ WHY OPTIONS ARE CORRECT/INCORRECT:
✅ Option 2 (Correct): $67,050 is the correct ending investment balance under the equity method. Since Sterling owns a 30% interest and has significant influence, it must use the equity method (ASC 323). The initial cost of the investment is 500 shares * $120 = $60,000. Under the equity method, the investor records its proportionate share of the investee’s earnings or losses from the date of acquisition. For Year 1, Dalton reported a $24,000 net loss over 12 months ($2,000 per month). Because Sterling acquired the stock on October 1, it only owns the shares for 3 months of Year 1. Sterling's share of the Year 1 loss is $24,000 * 3/12 * 30% = $1,800, which reduces the investment account. In Year 2, Sterling records its share of Dalton's net income: $35,000 * 30% = $10,500, which increases the investment account. Finally, dividends received under the equity method reduce the investment balance as a return of capital: 500 shares * $2.50 = $1,250. This yields an ending balance of $60,000 - $1,800 + $10,500 - $1,250 = $67,050. Changes in stock market fair value are completely ignored because the fair value option was not elected.
❌ Option 1 (Incorrect): $57,250 is derived by incorrectly subtracting the full 12 months of Dalton's Year 1 net loss ($24,000 * 30% = $7,200) instead of pro-rating it for the 3 months of actual ownership ($60,000 - $7,200 + $10,500 - $1,250).
❌ Option 3 (Incorrect): $68,300 is derived by failing to subtract the Year 2 cash dividends received from the investment asset balance ($60,000 - $1,800 + $10,500).
❌ Option 4 (Incorrect): $85,000 is a distractor value that represents a completely incorrect application of fair value changes or failing to account for the losses and dividends under equity tracking rules.
📊 SUMMARY CALCULATIONS:
- Initial Investment Cost = 500 shares * $120 = $60,000
- Year 1 Pro-rated Investee Loss Share = $24,000 * (3 / 12 months) * 30% = -$1,800
- Year 2 Investee Income Share = $35,000 * 30% = +$10,500
- Year 2 Dividends Received = 500 shares * $2.50 = -$1,250
- Ending Investment Balance = $60,000 - $1,800 + $10,500 - $1,250 = $67,050